A reed that grows in the mud at the edge of ponds, with a rhizome that smells of cinnamon and tangerine when you cut it. Sweet flag was one of the most important medicines of the medieval world — and it is now substantially restricted, because of one compound.
Sweet flag contains beta-asarone, a phenylpropanoid that has been shown to be carcinogenic in animal studies and to cause chromosomal damage. The European Union banned sweet flag as a food additive in 2002, and the US FDA prohibits it in food. The Asian and American varieties contain far more beta-asarone than the European one — and most commercial material is not identified to variety, which is precisely why the safe path is not to consume it at all.
Historically, extremely widely. It is a warming carminative and a stimulant, used for cold digestion, for a chesty cough, for fever, for toothache (the root chewed), and — in the Ayurvedic tradition as vacha — as a nerve tonic and a memory aid, often combined with brahmi.
The smell is a clue to its traditional use. Aromatic warming herbs with that profile were, across many cultures, used for exactly the same set of complaints: a cold stomach, a congested chest, a foggy head. That consistency is real; it is simply not a reason to accept a known carcinogen in the dose.
The closest safe substitutes for sweet flag's warming, aromatic, digestive action are ginger, cardamom and cinnamon — all warming carminatives, all safe in food amounts, none with a beta-asarone problem. For the cognitive tradition, rosemary and brahmi occupy similar ground.
At a glance