Sweet cicely has one trick no other herb in this library can match: cooked with acidic fruit, it reduces the amount of sugar you need. Not by sweetening — by muting the sourness. A rhubarb crumble made with a handful of its leaves needs roughly half the sugar.
The leaves contain anethole — the same compound that gives aniseed and fennel their flavour — plus a natural sweetness from sugars in the leaf itself. Cooked into fruit, the anethole rounds off the sharp edge of the acid, so your tongue reads the dish as sweeter than it is.
Green aniseed — softer and more herbaceous than fennel, with a faint celery note underneath. The young seed pods are the best part: pale green, elongated, and genuinely sweet to chew on.
Sweet cicely is a gentle carminative, used the same way fennel and aniseed are — for wind, bloating and a sluggish stomach after a heavy meal. It is also traditionally taken as a spring tonic: the young leaf eaten in salads and the root cooked as a vegetable, both intended to "clear the blood" after winter. The modern reading of that is simply that it is a pleasant, aromatic, mildly digestive green appearing at exactly the right time of year.
It was also a traditional remedy for coughs in northern Europe, and the seeds were chewed for bad breath. Both are reasonable applications of an aromatic herb and neither has strong trial support. Treat sweet cicely as a culinary herb with a digestive bonus rather than a treatment for anything.
Sweet cicely is in the Apiaceae (carrot) family, and it looks uncomfortably similar to several deadly relatives — most importantly hemlock and rough chervil. The safe test: sweet cicely smells strongly and sweetly of aniseed the moment a leaf is crushed, and its stem is ridged and slightly hairy. Hemlock smells musty and unpleasant and has purple blotches on a smooth stem. If you are not completely certain, do not forage it. Grow it instead — it is an easy, handsome plant for a shady corner.
At a glance